Bug#683554: RM: horde3 and reverse dependencies -- ROM; Obsolete version

clone 683554 -1
clone 683554 -2
clone 683554 -3
clone 683554 -4
clone 683554 -5
clone 683554 -6
clone 683554 -7
clone 683554 -8
clone 683554 -9
clone 683554 -10
clone 683554 -11
clone 683554 -12
clone 683554 -13
clone 683554 -14
clone 683554 -15
clone 683554 -16
retitle 683554 RM: horde3 -- ROM; Obsolete
retitle -1 RM: ansel1 -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
retitle -2 RM: chora2 -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
retitle -3 RM: dimp1 -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
retitle -4 RM: gollem -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
retitle -5 RM: horde-sam -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
retitle -6 RM: imp4 -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
retitle -7 RM: ingo1 -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
retitle -8 RM: kronolith2 -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
retitle -9 RM: mnemo2 -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
retitle -10 RM: nag2 -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
retitle -11 RM: sork-forwards-h3 -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
retitle -12 RM: sork-passwd-h3 -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
retitle -13 RM: sork-vacation-h3 -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
retitle -14 RM: turba2 -- ROM: Depend on obsoleted horde3
reassign -15 release.debian.org
reassign -16 release.denian.org
retitle -15 RM: php-kolab-filter/0.1.9-4.1
retitle -16 RM: php-kolab-freebusy/0.1.5-3
user
usertags -15 rm
usertags -16 rm
thanks

Hi!


* Mathieu Parent [120801 19:08]:

Please remove the following packages from unstable (then
testing/wheezy), they are obsolete|1] and not supported anymore:

[..]

Will do, but we need sepperate bug reports for them, hence the clones
above. Please note that we (as the ftp team) will remove the packages
only from unstable. The removal of these packages however should
propagate to testing automatically (as soon as it would brake any
reverse-depends; as you want all remover that should happen pretty
quickly).

Please also remove the following packages managed by the pkg-kolab
team, from testing only:
php-kolab-filter
php-kolab-freebusy

Removals from testing are done by the release team; cloning some bugs
for them, too.

The php-horde-* packages are meant to replace them (Horde >= 4).

Hmmm... As that is a quite trastic change you might want to propose a
paragraph for the release notes? IIRC that's done by filling a bug against
the package release-notes.

Best regars,
Alexander


To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact
Archive: http://lists.debian.org/

tags 683554 moreinfo
thanks

Hi again!

* Mathieu Parent [120801 19:08]:

Please remove the following packages from unstable (then
testing/wheezy), they are obsolete|1] and not supported anymore:
ansel1
chora2
dimp1
gollem
horde-sam
imp4
ingo1
kronolith2
mnemo2
nag2
sork-forwards-h3
sork-passwd-h3
sork-vacation-h3
turba2

As you probably noticed these packages are now gone from unstable, and
should also be removed from testing soonish.

However, there seems to be a problem with:

horde3

Trying to remove it results in:


# Broken Depends:
php-kolab-filter: php-kolab-filter
php-kolab-freebusy: php-kolab-freebusy

# Broken Build-Depends:
php-horde-activesync: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-alarm: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-argv: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-auth: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-autoloader: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-browser: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-cache: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-cli: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-compress: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-constraint: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-controller: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-core: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-crypt: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-data: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-date: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-date-parser: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-db: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-editor: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-exception: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-form: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-group: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-history: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-http: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-icalendar: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-image: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-imap-client: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-injector: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-itip: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-lock: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-log: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-logintasks: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-mail: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-mime: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-mime-viewer: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-nls: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-notification: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-perms: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-prefs: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-rdo: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-role: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-rpc: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-secret: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-serialize: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-sessionhandler: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-share: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-spellchecker: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-stream-filter: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-stream-wrapper: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-support: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-syncml: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-template: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-text-diff: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-text-filter: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-text-filter-csstidy: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-text-flowed: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-token: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-translation: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-tree: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-url: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-util: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-vfs: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-view: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-xml-element: pear-horde-channel
php-horde-xml-wbxml: pear-horde-channel
php-kolab-filter: pear-horde-channel
php-kolab-freebusy: pear-horde-channel



Breaking php-kolab-filter and php-kolab-freebusy is probably okay, as
you requested their removal from testing, however all the build-depends
on pear-horde-channel look like a problem. Maybe I missed something,
but I couldn't find an other package providing pear-horde-channel, nor
is there dummy package available build from a higher horde version.
Could you please check, that removing horde3 won't result in a lot FTBFS
bugs?


Best regards,
Alexander


To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact

clone 683554 -1
reassign -1 wnpp
retitle -1 RFP: pear-horde-channel -- PEAR Horde channel definition file
block 683554 by -1
thanks

2012/8/2 Alexander Reichle-Schmehl :

Hi again!

Hi, again ;-)

[...]

However, there seems to be a problem with:

horde3

Trying to remove it results in:


# Broken Depends:
php-kolab-filter: php-kolab-filter
php-kolab-freebusy: php-kolab-freebusy

# Broken Build-Depends:
php-horde-[replaced by]*: pear-horde-channel





Breaking php-kolab-filter and php-kolab-freebusy is probably okay, as
you requested their removal from testing, however all the build-depends
on pear-horde-channel look like a problem. Maybe I missed something,
but I couldn't find an other package providing pear-horde-channel, nor
is there dummy package available build from a higher horde version.
Could you please check, that removing horde3 won't result in a lot FTBFS
bugs?

Oh, I forgot this one! This is a very tiny package consisting of only
one file (/usr/share/php/.channels/pear.horde.org.reg). We[1] should
probably create a new source package, like pear-phpunit-channel and
pear-symfony-project-channel.

Before that, keep horde3 in unstable (I have created an RFP blocking this bug).

Cheers,
Mathieu Parent

[1]: anyone?


To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact